Wednesday, September 26, 2018

Anat Hoffman Dares to Take On Israel’s Orthodox Establishment. Can She Win?

Anat Hoffman Dares to Take On Israel’s Orthodox Establishment. Can She Win?

February 28, 2013 in 2013 March-April, Israel
13 Comments

Hoffman’s persistence on behalf of WOW has not gone unnoticed by Israeli politicians. “The Israeli government finally realized that its policy is causing serious damage in the U.S. among American Jews,” says Shmuel Rosner, a senior fellow at the Jewish People Policy Planning Institute. “That, together with the fact that American Jews are now more willing to be critical of Israel on certain issues, has really brought [Hoffman’s] struggle to the forefront. There is no serious security situation, which everyone can really rally around. That means that there is more room for discussion about domestic and political issues.”

In December,  Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu asked former Soviet dissident and Jewish Agency chair Natan Sharansky to suggest ways to make the holy site more inclusive. “The Prime Minister thinks the Western Wall has to be a site that expresses the unity of the Jewish people, both inside Israel and outside the state of Israel,” Ron Dermer, Netanyahu’s senior adviser, told reporters at the time. “He wants to preserve the unity of world Jewry. This is an important component of Israel’s strength.”

Sharansky, who is close to Netanyahu and an admired figure in the diaspora, has already received tens of thousands of emails. Insiders say that he is contemplating turning Robinson’s Arch into a plaza equal to the one at the Kotel. Rosner, who has written about the issue, says one of the first steps is to stop calling it Robinson’s Arch. “It’s a part of the Western Wall and so one of the first steps to finding a reasonable resolution is calling it what it is—the Kotel.”

When I spoke to Sachs, WOW’s director, in early January, she seemed amenable to this idea, but more recently her stance has hardened and she says the group is  reluctant to accept the Robinson’s Arch solution. “It’s not a place that Am Yisrael (the people of Israel) sees as sacred. Nobody closes their eyes, thinks of Zion and pictures Robinson’s Arch. That might change, but for now, it’s a solution that sends us to place we don’t want to go.” Sachs says the group would consider a solution that reconfigures the Kotel plaza to make space for them, or alternatively, a compromise whereby they have access to the Wall for only certain hours of the day.

The new Knesset is poised to take on the issue as well: MK Aliza Lavie of Yesh Atid (There is a Future), now the second largest political party in Israel’s parliament, has already said that she is planning to introduce a law redefining the Western Wall’s status. In reacting to the most recent spate of arrests, Lavie condemned WOW for defying the Supreme Court’s ruling, but she also said, “It’s sad to see how the Kotel, which is supposed to symbolize peace and fraternity in the Nation of Israel, has become a scene of constant bickering, which sometimes devolves into violence.”

Any compromise needs to reflect the fact that the Wall remains significant both religiously and nationally, says Yehudah Mirsky, a professor at Brandeis University’s Schusterman Center for Israel Studies and an ordained Orthodox rabbi. “We need to figure out a way to respect everyone’s needs,” he says. “On one hand, just like you can’t just go into the Vatican and do whatever you want, the solution needs to respect people’s religious sensibilities. But on the other hand, the Kotel is not just a religious site and as such, it’s not only the preserve of the haredim.”

The issue may boil down to simple politics. As Mirsky puts it, “The question is: Who is the constituency?” Unlike on the bus issue, the widespread Israeli populace has not embraced the cause of the Women of the Wall like American Jews have. American Jews, Mirsky says, “care passionately about Israel, but they need to recognize that they’re not Israeli citizens. If Anat Hoffman can raise public awareness and convince Israelis that this is their issue too, maybe it will make a difference, but otherwise, it’s hard to imagine there will be real political pressure to change.” He adds, “If an Israeli police commander has to choose between upsetting American Jews and angry editorials in American Jewish newspapers on one hand and tens of thousands of angry haredi men protesting in the streets of Jerusalem on the other, he will chose the former.”

Although the women’s arrests have been reported in Israel, they haven’t stirred up the indignation they have in the United States. It’s not even clear if Israeli feminists support Hoffman on the WOW front. “There are so many issues that are more central, like sexual harassment in the workplace, equal pay, adequate day care and having a longer school day,” says Marilyn Sapir, professor emeritus at the University of Haifa who founded Israel’s first gender studies program and was also the founder and director of the Israel Association for Feminist and Gender Studies. “Within feminist groups, people are aware of Anat and respect her work, but the whole question of women’s status in religious environments is much less significant to Israeli feminists.”

And what about her main opponents, the ultra-Orthodox? They argue that Hoffman’s PR offensive obscures the deeper issues. “What they are advocating is not freedom of religion—which is alive and well in Israel—but rather a redefinition of Judaism,” Rabbi Avi Shafran, director of public affairs for Agudath Israel of America, has written. Indeed, he sees the Western Wall as but one of the many issues that can potentially split Jewish society. “Would not ‘Messianic Jews,’ for example, assert a right to hold aloft crosses for their services at the Wall?  Or political activists of various stripes, to call rallies and demonstrations there?  How and where does one draw a logically consistent, legally defensible line?”

He later tells me, “For more than three decades, the Kotel has been a place—perhaps the only one in the world—where Jews of all affiliations and persuasions have regularly prayed side by side.  What has allowed for that minor miracle has been the maintenance of a standard at the holy site by which all Jews—even those who might choose other standards, or none at all, elsewhere—can abide.”

This is in line with the thinking of Shmuel Rabinowitz, rabbi of the Western Wall and chairman of the Western Wall Heritage Foundation, who has also blasted WOW, saying that their prayer groups are “meant as a show for the media.” (Earlier this year, WOW, along with a number of progressive Jewish groups in Israel, submitted a petition to the Israeli Supreme Court calling into question the Foundation’s legal status.) Women of the Wall and the entire Reform movement “are the only Jewish stream who received from the State of Israel its own private area for prayers at the Western Wall, at an investment of two million dollars of taxpayers’ money,” Rabinowitz has said, referring to the government’s costly improvements to Robinson’s Arch. “All the other tens of streams and substreams in the Jewish nation crowd together in the Western Wall Plaza in peace and brotherhood, with mutual respect, and not one of them complains ‘This place is too small.’”

Hoffman has another group of detractors who insist she’s giving the the Jewish state’s foes more ammunition. “This gives Israel’s enemies another issue they can sink their teeth into,” said Morton Klein, national president of the Zionist Organization of America, who calls Hoffman’s agenda “shockingly anti-Israel.” “If they cared deeply about Judaism and Israel they would quietly work something out. What they’re doing is not beneficial to anyone.”

Klein is curious if Hoffman, who is a Reform Jew and a member of Jersualem’s Reform Kol Haneshama synagogue, regularly lays tefillin and prays at synagogue—or whether this is just a publicity stunt. “I once asked a member of the group and she walked away in a huff. But I want to know: How much does ritual Judaism really matter to them? I’m not sure.”

WOW has heard these criticisms before, but insists it is not trying to be confrontational just for the sake of getting attention. “All we’re trying to do is pray,” says Sachs. “Many of us are in our 40s, 50s and 60s. We’re fighting for what’s human, and the majority of the Jewish people think we’re doing the right thing.”

It’s safe to say that in the united states, Hoffman is a celebrity with a fan club. At a recent lunchtime gathering in Washington, DC, Hoffman regales about two dozen people—mostly women—with her popular stump speech, which includes stories, jokes and pithy one-liners. “Love is what remains when we know the truth,” she says, followed by “Israel is too important to be left to Israelis.” Hoffman exudes energy as she talks and her audience hangs on to her every word, nodding their heads in approval, and responding to her with laughter and applause.

Hoffman, I learn afterward, has studied stand-up comedy, and it clearly shows. When she began speaking publicly, she wanted to master the skill and so with her signature fierceness, she took stand-up comedy classes, which allowed her to fine-tune her rhythm, as well as hone her ability to deliver punch lines. She also read books about great speeches, studying the subtleties that made them memorable.

She recounts her vision of Israel to the rapt audience. “The Zionist dream is much bigger than just trying to save bodies. It’s about building a society that is based on Jewish values.” Her mission, she tells me later, is to uphold Israel’s Declaration of Independence, which according to the text, “ensures complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex, and guaranteed freedom of religion, conscience, language, education and culture.”

After she steps down from the podium, she is surrounded by a swarm of women, some with questions and others eager to buy WOW’s tallit. “Diaspora Jews have power,” she says. “We need to widen what it means to be patriotic, what it means to be supportive. American Jews are on a well-worn path to support Israel, but there’s not only one way.” She looks up and smiles, adding, “I refuse to put a lid on it.”

 

13 Comments
  • muriel weinstein 19:13h, 28 February Reply

    This is a little known story in New York City & environs. How come our papers haven’t picked it up. It’s a n uplifting bio of a future leader…a leader of Israel. She has the stuff needed to fight the Orthodox who do Israel NO FAVOR by NOT accepting Israel as a state, by NOT entering the draft, by NOT publicly through news media all over the world, proclaiming only ORTHODOX JEWS are the REAL JEWS>. Insisting all the others are NOT Jews. I am proud to be a Woman when I read of women like Anat. Israel needs her as she could be the next LEADER.

  • anat hoffman 07:22h, 03 March Reply

    I am so grateful . What a shot in the arm ,a kick in the pants ,a moment of pride.

  • George Fredlund 16:07h, 04 March Reply

    I am proud of being human because of people like Anat Hoffman.
    G-d bless her and her work for equality.

  • Judy Miller 19:02h, 10 March Reply

    I’m sorry, but I feel that this woman is an opportunist who is using the Kotel, the tallit, and the sefer Torah as props for her own self-glorification. She has made a career of this and would be devastated if she were ignored by the Orthodox world. That they react as they do only allows Ms. Hoffman to continue, not to liberate women ( most of whom have zero interest in her shrill rants) but to put herself and her secular agenda in everyone’s faces. There are myriads of women who feel as I do, that she is divisive and a menace and rather than trying to unite the Jewish people, she wishes to further fragment us.

    • Susan Esther Barnes 20:12h, 20 March Reply

      Judy –

      Clearly you have never discussed this issue with Anat Hoffman. Therefore, you have no idea whatsoever how she would feel if she were ignored by the Orthodox world. As a person who has spoken with her, it is clear to me that she would be delighted if the Orthodox would leave her and the Women of the Wall alone to pray in peace.

      Judaism teaches us that we should not question the motivations of people when it is possible their motives are pure. I believe Anat Hoffman’s motives are, indeed, pure.

      Furthermore, her “agenda” is certainly not secular. Secular people, by definition, do not wish to do religious things. What Anat Hoffman and the Women of the Wall seek to do is to pray at the Kotel, wearing religious ritual objects. Not only are they not secular, many of them are religious Orthodox Jews.

    • Suzy 22:37h, 10 May Reply

      Judy,
      It would be wonderful if the Orthodox would ignore her. But , while the Orthodox want the freedom to practice Judaism as they wish, something that has been all too rare in our history, they are not willing to allow people to respectfully worship as they choose.
      Frankly, their actions have been a shame and embarrassment to the majority of the Jewish people. Being an American I am grateful for our tradition of separation of church and state. I will continue fighting the extreme right wing Christians here who keep trying to impose Christianity on our government.

  • jew in jerusalem 12:30h, 12 March Reply

    I wish Anat Hoffman and her Women of the Wall would seek sincere dialogue with the native-born residents of Jerusalem rather then forcing her way once a month with her prayer protests. There are many quiet, spiritual women who just want to come to the Wall to pray, as opposed to fighting against “the other”.

  • Marilyn Rivkin Crossley 00:29h, 24 March Reply

    I greatly admire Anat Hoffman and Women of the Wall and am grateful for the work they do for all of us who cannot be with them each month as they pray and represent those who believe in the equality of all to pray as they wish at the Kotel. I was last in Israel in 2005, praying on a Rosh Chodesh with WOW and had the ugly experience of being spat at by an old Orthodox woman who seemed to think that made her statement viable. God bless Anat! I cannot wait to meet her at TBE in Wellesley, MA in April!

  • Victor E Sacjse 20:00h, 24 March Reply

    Israel can never be a state that is truly representative of the Jewish people so long as the Ultra-Orthodox rabbinate has any control. That Jewish women are barred from pryaing at the Western Wall in the manner in which they choose to pray is utterly reprehensible. Equally reprehensible is the continuing rejection of Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist conversions, and, now even some Orthodox conversions. Far too many Jews are denied rights in Israel that they enjoy virtually everywhere else.

  • Ruth Berman 14:30h, 30 May Reply

    Since Judaism prides it’ self on being monolithic those
    we call “ultra” (a different discussion about that word) orthodox want us to be “one’ and behave and practice according to their ‘One way” or the “highway”.
    it’s not their business. Their way is mysoginy and that is unacceptable to me.
    and woman who thinks Hoffman is an opportunist is so off base and someone who probably hasn’t taken an initiatives to correct wrongs, herself.
    The Women of the Wall have been given permission to pray and the”ultra” or any level of judaism that disagrees with them need to be quiet and respectful of that.

  • moriah 14:11h, 14 July Reply

    meh…

  • Joanna 06:29h, 15 July Reply

    She is the worst. I am not ultra orthodox- just plain old orthodox and to read this glowing article about a heretic, rabble rouser and essentially self promoting person is completely sickening. If she was a legitimate lover of Judaism, she wouldn’t have spent her entire life trying to bend it to her will. She wants plurality except if it bothers Orthodox Jews- because apparently they’ve had the control for too long. She is a true embarrassment to our people and I pray that she stops her worthless and divisive crusade to make Judaism whatever SHE thinks it should be.

  • What Rosh Hodesh Means for Jewish Democracy | Jewish Voices Together 02:06h, 21 August Reply

    […] seeking to connect with our ancient traditions and God’s presence. Recently, there have been many arrests and much discord and violence, arising from Haredi objections to the women davening out loud, wearing tallit or […]

Post A Comment