Tuesday, July 16, 2019

Can There Be Judaism Without Belief In God?

Can There Be Judaism Without Belief In God?

November 16, 2011 in 2011 September-October, Arts & Culture, Symposium

Robert Putnam

I don’t know whether it’s theologically kosher to be both a Jew and an atheist, but if it isn’t, half the Americans who call themselves Jews aren’t quite legit. Of self-identified Jews in the nationally representative surveys David Campbell and I did for our book American Grace, 50 percent say they have doubts about the existence of God. That figure is much higher among Jews than any other major religious group in America. (Among members of all other faiths, only 10-15 percent express any doubts at all about God’s existence.) Indeed, the fraction of atheists among self-described Jews is not much lower than among so-called “nones,” people who say they have no religious affiliation at all. Of the “nones,” 53 percent have doubts about God’s existence.

Jews are an ethnicity and a community, not just a religion. To be sure, that’s true of other religions, to some extent. Part of what it means to be an Italian, Polish or Irish American is being Catholic, and the Black church is at the core of the African-American community. So Jews are not alone in being partly an ethnic grouping, but community bonds play an unusually prominent role in our religion. I’m a Jew by choice—I converted 50 years ago, and I’m even more satisfied with that choice now than I was a half-century ago. That’s partly because being Jewish is mostly not about beliefs, but about connections with other people, sharing values and a collective destiny. Even for non-observant Jews, Jewish values are embodied in the Torah. Most Jews, unlike most Christians, don’t take the Torah literally, but it’s an exceptional account of the shared history and values of our people. Those values include respect for learning—we’re the “People of the Book”—respect for the individual, and pervasive concern about the fate of the community. It’s not an accident that Jews are among the most generous people in America philanthropically, and not just for Jewish causes; this trait embodies tikkun olam. Sociologically, Jews behave in a way that’s consistent with putting a high value on caring for other people, as well as on respect for learning. Even the atheists among us share those values.

Robert Putnam is the author of Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community and the Malkin Professor of Public Policy at Harvard University.


Marcia Falk

Without question, there always has been Judaism without God. For one thing, who decides whether what we do is Judaism or not? Is there some court on high that says, “This is Jewish, and this is not”? Clearly, a large population of Jews in America do not believe in God, though they may not say so. It’s very taboo in America to admit you’re an atheist. We can’t imagine a candidate for president who doesn’t go around God-blessing everything. It’s almost a century since Mordecai Kaplan, the founder of Reconstructionist Judaism, wrote Judaism as a Civilization, and the idea that Judaism has evolved over time is hardly a new concept. Even asking the question, “Can there be Judaism without God?” seems odd. Lots of people who don’t believe in God are going along living and being Jewish, so obviously they exist. People used to ask, “Can Judaism survive without halacha?” And it certainly has in the non-Orthodox movements. Same with God. If you say the community is only those who believe in God, you’ll have a pretty paltry community. What would they ask? Some kind of oath as to what you believe? Obviously that’s oppressive. At the bottom of these questions is a mindset that wants to appeal to an external authority saying what’s kosher and what isn’t. What are we asking for? Are we asking for permission?

Marcia Falk, a poet, translator and liturgist, is the author of The Book of Blessings: New Jewish Prayers for Daily Life, the Sabbath, and the New Moon Festival.

  • Age of Treason Radio: Jewish Crypsis – Wannabe Jews | JewishProblem.com 11:27h, 18 September Reply

    […] Can There Be Judaism Without Belief In God? Robert Putnam, author of Bowling Alone, […]

  • Jewish Crypsis – Wannabe Jews | Pragmatic Witness 00:43h, 30 September Reply

    […] Can There Be Judaism Without Belief In God? Robert Putnam, author of Bowling Alone, […]

  • Judaism Without Belief in God? | Havurat Ee Shalom 13:36h, 22 August Reply

    […] Moment asked the same question to 13 others notables,  ranging from philosophers to politicians to poets.  Read all the responses here at  Moment Online. […]

  • Morrie Nuison 19:56h, 06 November Reply

    What are we asking for? I can only speak for myself. I’d like some nice gefilte fish, and then corned beef on rye with mayo. That’s right – with mayo.

  • Davida Brown 14:37h, 04 April Reply

    ”Moses once said, according to God: “Moreover the Lord your God will circumcise your heart and the heart of your descendants, to love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul, so that you may live.” Deuteronomy 30:6
    The New Covenant scriptures (the New Testament) states, through the Apostle Paul (formerly known as Saul): “For he is not a Jew who is one outwardly; nor is circumcision that which is outward in the flesh. But he is a Jew who is one inwardly; and circumcision is that which is of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter; and his praise is not from men, but from God.” Romans 2:28 & 29
    Yes, the New Covenant scriptures are Jewish…Jeremiah 31:31 clearly states that the New Covenant is for the house of Israel and the house of Judah. The Gentiles are not even mentioned here!

    • henry gottlieb 16:20h, 14 June Reply

      GooblyGook, in its best masquerade Try reading what you have written… meaningless words..
      altho I am a jew, go to temple, observe the mayo on corned beef rule… folks like you make it hard for me to believe anything

  • David Cohen 02:43h, 11 October Reply

    Assess the validity of ideas on how well they stand up to scrutiny, not on the character or personality of those who profess to believe them.

Post A Comment