New Call-to-action

Sunday, October 22, 2017

Jewish Word / Sechel

Jewish Word / Sechel

November 1, 2013 in 2013 November-December, Arts & Culture
8 Comments

The (Jewish) Sixth Sense 

By George E. Johnson

In his autobiography, Songs My Mother Taught Me, Marlon Brando writes at length about the transformative role Jews played in his personal development in the 1940s. At the conclusion of his tribute to Jews and Judaism, Brando tries to reduce what is special about Jews to a single word: sechel. “There’s a Yiddish word, seychel [sic], that provides a key explaining the most profound aspects of Jewish culture,” he says. “It means to pursue knowledge and to leave the world a better place than when you entered it… It must be this cultural tradition that accounts for their amazing success, along with Judaism, the one constant that survived while the Jews were dispersed around the world.” With these words, Brando tapped deep into the multi-layered meanings of the word sechel, a word that is as old as the Jewish people and plays a key role in the moral and cultural conceptions of Jewish life.

Sechel is both a Hebrew and a Yiddish word, the Hebrew meanings having been absorbed into Yiddish. Pronounced sekhel in Modern/Israeli Hebrew and seykhel in Yiddish, it can mean intelligence, smarts, brains, reason, common sense, cleverness or even wisdom. Sechel is defined in the authoritative Eben Shoshan Hebrew Dictionary as “the spiritual ability to think, to weigh, the strength to judge and to come to a resolution.” Michael Swirsky, an Israel-based educator and translator of Hebrew texts, distinguishes sechel from chochma, and other Hebrew words for wisdom, as “a trait, like IQ or good sense” that one is endowed with. “Chochma, binah and da’at,” Swirsky explains, “are skills, talents or traits that could take a lifetime to acquire.”




I'd like to subscribe to Moment's weekly e-newsletter.




At home in many a Yiddish proverb, sechel is generally considered to be an enviable quality. A typical piece of advice: “With a horse you look at the teeth; with a person, you look at their sechel.” Another: “For money you get everything except sechel.” Or: “Ask advice from everyone, but act with your own sechel.” However, it often is used as a not-so-subtle negative jibe. In his 2008 book, Just Say Nu: Yiddish for Every Occasion When English Just Won’t Do, Michael Wex notes with not a small touch of irony that “Yiddish is blessed with a wealth of expressions to describe anyone less intelligent than the speaker,” including such gems as “She has as many brains (saykhl) as a church has mezuzahs!”

Contemporary use of sechel, however, gives little hint of the more serious moral and ethical undercurrents of the word in religious texts. Sechel, and related forms of the term such as maskil and l’haskil, appear more than a hundred times in the Bible. Sechel first appears in the third chapter of Genesis, when Eve comments that the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil is “desirable as a means to wisdom [l’haskil].” Here the Bible introduces the moral lesson that wisdom can be used for good or for evil, a theme found in later Jewish texts as well. There are, however, numerous biblical references to sechel that foreshadow its contemporary use as “common sense” linked to action. When Jacob intentionally switches his right and left hands in order to give Ephraim, rather than Manasseh, the blessing of the first-born, the word describing this maneuver is seekhayl. In another example, Avigail, whose husband insults King David’s men, tries to appease the king with a bounty of gifts and is described in the text as a woman “of good understanding,” v’ha-isha tovat sechel.

Sechel is also the root of haskalah, the Hebrew word meaning enlightenment, and the name of the 18th- and 19th-century movement that introduced European Jewry to secular ideas and society. As a result, traditionalist religious leaders associated sechel and its derivatives with apostasy. To the maskilim, or enlightened ones, sechel meant ridding Jews of superstitions and stultifying old ways, according to Jack Kugelmass, a Jewish studies professor at the University of Florida. Kugelmass adds that sechel no longer carries these connotations—were he to use the word sechel in class today, his fourth- and fifth-generation students wouldn’t know what he is talking about.

Despite this, plenty of people continue to find sechel useful. It keeps popping up in some unexpected places. A rather curious example is Sechel: Logic Language and Tools to Manage Any Organization as a Network, an organizational management manual by a non-Jewish business strategist named Domenico Lepore. Lepore explains that intuitive insights derived from the study of Chabad Hasidism led him to identify various “faculties” of intellect to improve organization performance. “Only with an acquired sechel,” Lepore explains, “is it possible to manage successfully a conscious and connected organization, one that recognizes the systemic, network and project-like intrinsic nature of the work of any enterprise.”

Why hasn’t sechel entered the English lexicon, like many other commonly used Yiddish words, such as mensch or chutzpah? “Sechel has not been commonly used for several decades by Jews in their interactions with non-Jews,” says Sarah Bunin Benor, professor of contemporary Jewish studies at Hebrew Union College and creator of the online “Jewish English Lexicon,” which contains 855 words from Yiddish, Hebrew and other languages used by American Jews within English. One explanation may be that in contrast to words like mensch and chutzpah, which have no simple equivalent in English, the principal meanings of sechel—common sense and wisdom—are fully captured in English.

There are those who would say that the world is in desperate need of sechel, whatever language it is expressed in. Says Yiddish scholar and Harvard professor Ruth Wisse: “Three things always come too late—wisdom [sechel], regret and the fire brigade.”

Tags:
8 Comments
  • Dr Norman Berman 00:19h, 23 November Reply

    How did Marlon Brando learn about sechel? How did he become interested in Judaism? This was a very interesting article. I was talking about it with my Korean friend and she said there is a similar word (which I don’t remember) in Korean which means something like “street smart” or sechel.
    Maybe Ii can use this article for a discussion for our Havurah.

    • George E. Johnson 21:27h, 04 December Reply

      Thank you for your comments. In his “Songs My Mother Taught Me,” Brando describes how in the 1940s, when he lived in New York City, which included a year at the New School for Social Research, he lived in a very Jewish world. Jews were his friends, teachers and employers. He describes how he spent long hours talking with them and how these contacts opened up his world intellectually and helped him mature as a person and as an actor. Brando does not recount specific instances of how he learned about the Jewish experience and Judaism, but he did. He expresses how he empathized with the the Jews’ struggles in that period and describes his efforts to help the Jewish settlement in Palestine. He also does not specifically explain how he picked up the word sechel, but he appears to have been an acute student of human nature and was attracted to the character qualities he not only observed but himself picked up. In the book he attempts to capture these qualities with the word sechel.

  • D. Zimmermann 16:42h, 15 June Reply

    I would be most grateful to have the following string translated by you. I told a jewish friend that I would be able to read and basically understand biblical Hebrew (with aids of course) and he gave me this bit of text to check whether my Hebrew was kosher 😉 Well, I failed miserably. The main stumbling block remaining is baaja, now that you have explained sechel so subtly. Thanks.

    ma ha baaja shel cha im jeschiahu, she atha mebalbel po et ha sechel.

    • Sarah Breger 09:58h, 17 June Reply

      Do you have the phrase in Hebrew letters? That would make it easier to help.

  • Brit Hume’s silence and the ugly secret about Obama’s amnesty 19:25h, 20 November Reply

    […] shorn of polite language, boiled down to he’s really bright guy and pretty nice, but no sechel.  Or as Hume said, he illustrates the principle that one can be “smart, but not […]

  • Josef Raphael 14:04h, 26 February Reply

    I read the autobiographical book by Brando and even though it was a bit overly detailed I nonetheless enjoyed it and became fascinated with the ideology behind “sechel” which is why I created my organization/foundation to try to leave the world a better place than I found it…

  • L Hudson 21:51h, 13 April Reply

    Insightful and well written, this subtly encapsulates why I have always been enamored with Judaism. Thank you for sharing your wisdom, your sechel.

  • Tina 23:39h, 05 May Reply

    My brother mentioned this word to me about someone that we know that has no “morale or scruples”. I never heard the word before and I couldn’t stop laughing! I guess it’s applicable, cause if a person has a sense of honor or decency, that would be the intelligent thing to do. Therefore, they had no “sechel”!

Post A Comment